Data-driven arguments for better teacher contracts Β· Northeast PA
Contract documents on file Β· 11 districts Β· Northampton, Monroe, Lehigh & Berks CountiesThis compares what Nazareth pays at your step vs what a comparable district pays a teacher at the same step and lane. This is not a transfer analysis - it shows what each district's schedule pays at the same step. (Step placement for a teacher who transfers is set by each district and is not modelled here.)
How the years are projected (assumption, not contract data): Nazareth uses its 2023-24 through 2027-28 Agreement schedules for 2024-25 to 2027-28. Northampton uses its 2024-29 agreement (Exhibits AβE) through 2028-29. Every year after a district's last schedule on file is projected at an assumed 2.0% a year, and the same 2.0% is applied to every district, Nazareth included (after 2027-28). East Stroudsburg uses its 2024-30 agreement (Schedule A) through 2029-30. Parkland, Easton and Stroudsburg schedules on file end in 2024-25, so from 2025-26 on they are projections. Each year the teacher moves up one step until the district's top step. Where a district has no lane matching yours, the nearest lower lane on its schedule is used and named in the results below. Don't quote projected years at the table as contract figures.
A step freeze holds teachers on the same step for one or more years. Teachers who were frozen reach the top step later, and spend extra years earning below-top salaries. Enter the details to estimate the dollar cost at current (2024-25) schedule rates.
| District | Pays at this experience (2024-25 schedule) | vs. Nazareth top step | Note |
|---|
Pennsylvania allows up to 5 flexible instructional days per school year. FIDs count as full school days and do not need to be made up - eliminating the need for snow days to be tacked onto spring break. The question is how FIDs are implemented, and that's where districts differ.
| District | FID Model | Teacher Obligation | Student Expectation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nazareth Area β | Full synchronous bell schedule Includes ALL specials (art, PE, music, library) |
Follow regular class schedule all day online; same obligations as in-person day | Attend every class period at scheduled times via regular bell schedule |
| Easton Area | Asynchronous (grades K-12) | Post assignments; available to support; no live classes required | Complete assigned work; submit within defined window |
| West Chester Area (example) | Hybrid - some live, mostly async | Post assignments; some synchronous check-ins optional | Log in by 9 AM to confirm attendance; complete assignments |
| Proposed model (see language below) | Fully asynchronous OR 1hr AM + 1hr PM check-in | Post work AM; available via email/LMS; brief PM check-in; rest of day = personal time | Work independently; reach out for help; submit by deadline |
This chart shows how a teacher's salary grows year-over-year at each district, starting from Step 1 and advancing through all available steps.
| Step | Nazareth (MA, 2024-25) | Northampton Area (MA, 2024-25, 2024-29 agreement) | Annual Gap (Northampton minus Nazareth) + Cumulative |
|---|
Nazareth's schedule raises in 2024-25 and 2025-26 (about 1% at BA Step 1; 2.0% and 1.5% at MA Step 16) are below the CPI figures used on this site. Where that holds, teachers' real purchasing power declines even though they get a raise. The CPI series here is the same one used on the District Comparison page (Philadelphia-area CPI-U, BLS). The 2025-26 to 2027-28 CPI values are projections, not measured inflation.
| Year | Nazareth Salary (Step 1 BA) | Nominal Raise | Philadelphia CPI | Real Change | Purchasing Power (2023-24 $) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023-24 | $55,668 | - (no 2022-23 schedule on file) | 4.4% (not counted) | - | $55,668 |
| 2024-25 | $56,253 | +1.05% | 3.6% | -2.5% | $54,298 |
| 2025-26 | $56,815 | +1.00% | 3.2% (proj.) | -2.1% | $53,140 |
| 2026-27 | $57,951 | +2.00% | 2.5% (proj.) | -0.5% | $52,881 |
| 2027-28 | $59,632 | +2.90% | 2.3% (proj.) | +0.6% | $53,191 |
| NET (2023-24 β 2027-28) | +$3,964 | +7.12% | +12.1% cumulative (2024-25 β 2027-28) | -4.4% | -$2,477 vs the 2023-24 salary |
Method (same as the District Comparison page): 2023-24 is the baseline year. Cumulative inflation compounds the CPI column from 2024-25 on, 1.036 Γ 1.032 Γ 1.025 Γ 1.023 = 1.121. Purchasing power divides each year's salary by the cumulative CPI through that year, so it is in 2023-24 dollars. No 2022-23 Nazareth schedule is on file, so the 2023-24 raise isn't known and 2023-24 inflation is not counted against it. CPI values are not from a contract document; confirm them with BLS before citing. 2025-26 to 2027-28 CPI values are projections.
Nazareth's schedule tops out at Step 16: $101,877 in the MA lane and $103,788 at M+45 (2024-25). On MA-lane maximums, $101,877 is the highest of the 11 districts shown. At M+45 it is $1,101 above Northampton's 2024-25 top ($102,687) and $1,139 below Parkland's ($104,927). Where Nazareth trails is the climb: Northampton, Parkland and Easton reach their top in 15 steps and pay more at the entry steps.
| District (2024-25 schedule) | Max Steps | Starting (MA) | Max Salary (MA lane) | Salary at Step 16 (MA) | vs Nazareth (entry / max) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nazareth Area | 16 (terminal) | $58,836 | $101,877 | $101,877 | - |
| Northampton Area (2024-29 agreement) | 15 | $64,403 | $95,787 | $95,787 (Step 15 = max) | +$5,567 at entry; -$6,090 at max |
| Parkland SD (2022-25 contract, expired) | 15 | $71,129 | $92,927 | $92,927 (Step 15 = max) | +$12,293 at entry; -$8,950 at max |
| Easton Area (2022-25 contract, expired) | 15 | $66,500 | $96,690 | $96,690 (Step 15 = max) | +$7,664 at entry; -$5,187 at max |
Estimate β source needed: none of the statewide or district-finance figures on this tab comes from a contract or source file on hand. Confirm each one with NCES, BLS or the PDE Annual Financial Reports before citing it.
| District | Exp/Pupil | vs. Nazareth | Local Revenue % | Student-Teacher Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Saucon Valley SD | $20,498 | +$3,392 (+20%) | 73% | 13.41 |
| Pen Argyl Area SD | $18,661 | +$1,555 (+9%) | 61% | 12.12 |
| Bangor Area SD | $17,774 | +$668 (+4%) | 57% | 13.91 |
| Nazareth Area SD | $17,106 | - | 72% | 14.36 |
Key arguments for the next NAEA contract negotiation. Salary figures are from the contract documents on file and are 2024-25 unless a year is given. Items marked "estimate β source needed" must be confirmed before use.
Pick districts, metrics, and chart type - mix and match freely. Steps metric is always inverted: fewer steps = faster to max = better.